Check out the animated show Bat out of Hell on YouTube!

Angels with Dirty Faces

In Kierkegaardian terms, the priest in Angels with Dirty Faces represents not so much the religious sphere as the ethical. This is not a movie of ultimate concerns or the paradoxes of faith, but of the either/or dichotomy of esthetic damnation (represented by the gangster milieu) versus “being good” and creating a good and wholesome community–characterized by rec centers and young men playing basketball rather than engaging in vandalism and petty larceny. Pat O’Brien, as the priest and former teenage hoodlum, cuts a pretty good figure. He’s a sensitive, intelligent priest, but also a dude who is capable of (a) decking some jerk in a barroom altercation and (b) taking on organized crime and enlisting the support of the media in order to create a place where young men have a fighting chance to grow into upstanding citizens. His childhood pal, Rocky, played by James Cagney, upstages him of course, and is the life force of the movie; but Fr. Jerry proves a powerful influence on Rocky. Aside from Cagney’s dynamic performance, the film has a lot to recommend it–including an outstanding performance by a young Humphrey Bogart as a slick and subtly sleazy lawyer who gets [spoiler alert] righteously capped by Rocky in due course. Cagney’s Rocky is a charismatic character and there is a running motif in scene after scene that highlights how his genius as a gangster is not unlike the genius of an actor playing roles. At the end, that acting motif rises to a new level, being enlisted by Fr. Jerry in the cause of the ethical–and it is quite a stunning finish. Does it have anything to do with faith? Well, maybe not, although Cagney’s charisma and verve, and the brilliance of Rocky’s own performances, perhaps indicate a trajectory in the direction of the religious sphere where we might assume Fr. Jerry ultimately dwells.

Priest portrayal grade: C+
Overall grade: A-

[Return to 52 Movies for the Year of the Priest home page.]


  1. Marc Magisana says

    Good old movie – in the Kierkegaardian sense, I see Cagney as the aesthetic hero (not hard to see him as prototype of gangsta/rocker) and O'Brien as the ethical (defender of bourgeois). Too bad they didn't include a 3rd religous type hero for transcendence (claude rains?)

Speak Your Mind